3 Reds-White Sox Trade Proposals For Garrett Crochet

The Cincinnati Reds are interested in Chicago White Sox left-handed pitcher Garrett Crochet, following their recent trade with the Kansas City Royals for Brady Singer. Crochet’s dominant performance in 2023 and two remaining years of team control have generated excitement among fans. The Reds’ current rotation includes pitchers like Hunter Greene, Nick Lodolo, Andrew Abbott, and Brady Singer, but Crochet could add another dynamic arm to the mix. Three potential trade proposals for Crochet include:

Major Prospect Package

Reds Receive: Garrett Crochet (LHP)

White Sox Receive: Sal Stewart (IF), Sammy Stafura (SS), Chase Petty (RHP), Lyon Richardson (RHP)

The Reds are rebuilding and looking to acquire position players in exchange for their star pitcher. This first proposal centers around a hefty package of young talent from the Reds’ deep farm system. It would include Sal Stewart, a first-round pick with excellent plate discipline; Sammy Stafura, a high-upside infielder with solid defensive skills; Chase Petty, a promising right-handed pitcher; and Lyon Richardson, a former second-round pick.

High-Profile Prospect Swap

Reds Receive: Garrett Crochet (LHP)

White Sox Receive: Noelvi Marte (SS), Austin Hendrick (OF), Christian Encarnacion-Strand (1B)

This second proposal offers some of the Reds’ more high-profile prospects, such as Noelvi Marte, Austin Hendrick, and Christian Encarnacion-Strand. Marte’s combination of power and defensive potential at shortstop makes him an attractive trade piece, but his strikeout issues may lower his current value. Encarnacion-Strand‘s bat is his biggest asset, and moving him could help the Reds balance their roster while acquiring a top-tier arm.

A More Balanced Approach

Reds Receive: Garrett Crochet (LHP)

White Sox Receive: TJ Hopkins (OF), Cam Collier (3B), Andrew Abbott (LHP), Edwin Arroyo (SS)

The final trade proposal takes a more balanced approach, offering a mix of position players and pitching prospects that could align better with the White Sox’s needs. This package includes TJ Hopkins, a toolsy outfielder with a solid bat and strong defensive ability; Cam Collier, a promising young third baseman with an impressive hit tool; Andrew Abbott, a promising left-handed pitcher with a high strikeout rate; and Edwin Arroyo, a top shortstop prospect with excellent defensive ability and a developing bat.

In conclusion, the Reds’ interest in trading for Crochet is intriguing, especially considering his impressive 2023 season and two years of team control. However, any trade for Crochet will likely come at a steep price, as the White Sox are looking to rebuild around position players. If Cincinnati can balance its desire to improve the pitching staff while avoiding a complete depletion of their farm system, a trade for Crochet could be a major win. However, Nick Krall must ensure that such a trade is part of a larger, cohesive strategy for sustained success.