Ethan Page: Is He Living Up to His Hype or Falling Short?

Ethan Page entered AEW with a lot of fanfare. As a seasoned performer with a strong reputation from his time in impact wrestling and the indie circuit, many fans were excited to see him rise to the top of All Elite Wrestling. However, nearly a year into his AEW career, the question remains: Is Ethan Page living up to his hype, or is he falling short of the expectations set for him?

The Big Debut: What Went Wrong?

When Ethan Page made his debut at Revolution 2021, many fans thought it was just the beginning of something big. Hailing from Impact wrestling, Page had a solid track record of engaging storylines, impressive matches, and even championship runs. His arrival in AEW seemed like a move that would elevate his career and provide him with the opportunity to compete against some of the company’s top stars.

But something didn’t quite click. While Page’s charisma and skills were undeniable, he seemed to fade into the background amidst AEW’s overcrowded roster. AEW fans were hungry for fresh faces, and yet, despite Page’s potential, he was placed in various mid-card storylines and tag-team matches rather than being positioned as a major singles competitor. This left many to wonder: Is AEW failing to see what Page can offer? Or is Page not living up to his full potential?

Page’s first major feud in AEW was with Darby Allin, a young star who was already well-established. While the storyline was interesting, it didn’t quite elevate Page to the top of the card, as fans expected. Instead, the feud seemed more like a way for Darby to continue building momentum, leaving Page to remain in the shadows.

Where is Ethan Page going in AEW?

So, where does Ethan Page go from here? AEW’s booking decisions have been scrutinized by fans who feel like Page could be a top-tier performer if given the right storylines and a more serious role. His tag-team work with Scorpio Sky as part of The Men of the Year was entertaining but again felt more like filler content than a legitimate push for a title run.

Ethan Page has all the tools to be a breakout star in AEW: an incredible work ethic, a commanding presence on the microphone, and the in-ring talent to go toe-to-toe with the best. Yet something is holding him back from reaching the top. Could it be the current booking system that prioritizes established names? Perhaps AEW is simply unsure of how to position Page, or maybe there’s something missing from his character development.

One of the most significant challenges for Page is the abundance of top talent in AEW. Stars like Jon Moxley, Kenny Omega, and CM Punk are natural headline draws, and they dominate the main-event scene. This makes it incredibly difficult for someone like Ethan Page to break through, despite his undeniable talent.

But even within the midcard, there’s competition. Sammy Guevara, MJF, and Wardlow are all vying for attention, which leaves little room for someone like Page to rise above the rest. So, the question remains: is Page truly being held back by external factors, or is his lack of prominence a result of his own limitations?

What Needs to Change for Ethan Page to Reach His Potential?

If Ethan Page is ever going to be the superstar fans hoped for, there are a few changes that need to be made—both by AEW and by Page himself. First, AEW needs to take risks with Page’s character. He’s proven that he can play both the funny heel and the serious competitor, so it’s time to let him pick a direction and commit to it.

Many fans feel that Page could thrive in a more serious role, perhaps by joining the Dark Order or becoming a leader of his own faction. The company needs to create more substantial, high-profile storylines that allow Page to showcase his talents beyond tag-team matches or lower-card segments. After all, AEW has been great at creating stars—just look at MJF, Darby Allin, and Orange Cassidy—but Page seems to be stuck in neutral.

Additionally, Page must embrace a deeper character development to truly connect with the fans. While he’s a talented performer, his character still feels somewhat disconnected from the AEW audience. Whether it’s by showing vulnerability, adding layers to his motivations, or cutting more personal promos, Ethan Page needs to give fans a reason to invest in him emotionally.

Finally, AEW’s focus on building new talent could actually play in Page’s favor. There’s an opportunity for him to carve out a niche for himself by becoming one of the company’s leading veterans. As AEW continues to grow and evolve, Page could serve as a bridge between the up-and-coming stars and the established veterans. This would allow him to prove his worth not just as a performer but as a leader within the AEW locker room.

Can Ethan Page Finally Break Through?

The truth is, Ethan Page has the potential to be a major player in AEW, but something needs to change. Whether it’s through better character development, more prominent storylines, or a shift in how he’s booked, Page still has time to make an impact. AEW has an impressive roster, and sometimes the stars need time to find their place.

For now, Ethan Page seems to be in a holding pattern, neither sinking nor soaring. Whether he breaks out of that pattern and rises to the occasion remains to be seen. One thing is for sure: his journey is far from over, and the potential for greatness is still there—if AEW and Ethan himself are willing to take the necessary steps to unlock it.