Is Pat Surtain II the Best Cornerback for the Broncos? Four Denver CB Icons Weigh in on His Talent

In Denver, the legacy of exceptional cornerbacks is legendary. From Champ Bailey’s illustrious career with 26 Pro Bowls and 3 First-team All-Pro selections to Chris Harris Jr.’s crucial role in the Super Bowl 50 defense, the Broncos have a storied history of standout players. Now, Pat Surtain II is emerging as a new cornerstone for the team, prompting many to question if he is already the best in the franchise’s history.

Surtain, a first-round pick in 2021, has quickly made a name for himself as a Pro Bowl selection twice and a First-team All-Pro in 2022. His career statistics include 10 interceptions and 37 pass breakups. The Broncos’ commitment to him was solidified with a record-breaking four-year, $96 million contract, the highest for a cornerback in NFL history. This deal secures Surtain’s future in Denver through the 2029 season, underscoring the team’s belief in his potential. General Manager George Paton called the contract “a no-brainer,” demonstrating confidence in Surtain’s impact even amid the financial constraints following Russell Wilson’s signing.

As the Broncos prepare for their Monday night matchup against the Cleveland Browns, four legendary Denver cornerbacks shared their insights on Pat Surtain II’s skill set and his future in the league. Their assessments collectively confirm that Surtain possesses a rare blend of size, speed, agility, and composure, positioning him to potentially be the greatest in Broncos’ history.

The Attributes of a Top Cornerback

Standing at 6-foot-2 and weighing 202 pounds, Surtain is larger than most cornerbacks in the NFL, yet his athleticism rivals any player in the league. In a standout play during the Broncos’ Week 5 victory over the Las Vegas Raiders, Surtain made an impressive 100-yard pick-six, clocked at an astounding 20.92 mph—the fastest recorded pick-six speed of the season, according to NFL Next Gen Stats.

Joe Collier, a former Broncos defensive coordinator, praised Surtain’s physical attributes, noting that cornerbacks of his size typically struggle with speed and flexibility. “Surtain has it all—size, speed, and the agility needed to excel in this role,” Collier said.

Impeccable Technique and Mental Toughness

Surtain’s approach to the game is a testament to his preparation and attention to detail. Former Broncos cornerback Louis Wright, who once played at an elite level, commented, “Surtain’s ability to maintain perfect technique and always locate the ball is rare. He doesn’t just play his position—he dominates it.”

Champ Bailey, a Hall of Famer, spoke highly of Surtain’s focus and commitment. “He’s serious, dedicated, and intelligent—traits that set him apart as a future great,” Bailey said. Surtain’s poise under pressure is another standout characteristic. “He never panics and always plays with confidence,” said Harris, another former Broncos defensive star.

Facing Top Talent

This season, Surtain has been tasked with covering the top receiving threats in the league, from Davante Adams to DK Metcalf and DeAndre Hopkins. Despite these challenges, he has allowed only 182 yards in coverage up to Week 12 and boasts the lowest passer rating when targeted (47.6). His ability to limit opponents, often matching up against elite talent, solidifies his reputation as a top performer.

Legacy in the Making

Surtain’s journey from high school, where he trained under his father Patrick Surtain, a former Pro Bowl cornerback, to college at Alabama, laid the groundwork for his NFL success. Harris noted, “You can tell he’s been preparing for this his whole life.” Bailey echoed these sentiments, emphasizing Surtain’s drive to be among the best, saying, “Every time he steps on the field, he shows that he wants greatness.”

In an era where NFL cornerbacks must adapt to high-powered passing attacks, Surtain’s combination of athleticism, technique, and mental resilience makes him a standout. As he continues to mature, it’s clear that Pat Surtain II is not just building a name for himself but also aiming to solidify his status as the best cornerback in Denver Broncos history.