Myles Garrett goes on a rampage with Rebuild. Joe Thomas says Myles Garrett is weak and overrated⚡

In a dramatic turn of events, Myles Garrett has once again sparked controversy, this time over his outspoken concerns about the Cleveland Browns’ ongoing rebuild. The star pass rusher, known for his on-field dominance, has made his frustrations known—claiming that the Browns’ lack of progress is hindering his potential. However, the latest twist in this saga is that Joe Thomas, the Browns’ legendary former left tackle, has taken aim at Garrett’s complaints, labeling them as weak and overrated.

But what does this really mean for the Browns, and for Garrett’s future with the team? Is this just a case of star power clashing with the realities of a team in transition, or is Garrett’s dissatisfaction a sign of a larger issue? This article dives deep into the controversial exchange between the two Browns icons and what it could mean for Cleveland’s future.

Myles Garrett’s “Rebuild” Complaints: Are They Justified?

Myles Garrett has long been considered one of the most dominant defenders in the NFL. His combination of size, speed, and power has made him a force to be reckoned with. However, as the Browns have struggled to find sustained success, Garrett has increasingly voiced his concerns over the team’s direction. Recently, Garrett went on a rampage, complaining that the team’s rebuild was moving too slowly and holding back his potential.

While it’s not uncommon for star players to express frustrations during a rebuild phase, Garrett’s comments have raised eyebrows. Is he justified in his frustration, or is he simply looking for a scapegoat for his inability to lead the team to a championship?

The Browns, after all, have made significant moves in recent seasons. They’ve brought in high-profile players, changed coaches, and attempted to reshape their roster into one that can compete in the tough AFC North. Yet despite these efforts, the team has yet to break through to the next level. This is where Garrett’s frustration lies—he wants to win now, and he’s sick of waiting.

But is it really the team’s rebuild holding him back? Or is it something deeper?

Joe Thomas Calls Garrett Out: “Stop Complaining, Start Leading”

Enter Joe Thomas, the Browns’ legendary left tackle and a man who spent his entire career battling through years of rebuilding himself. After hearing Garrett’s complaints, Thomas couldn’t hold back. In a no-holds-barred critique, Thomas called Garrett’s whining weak and overrated, arguing that as a superstar, Garrett should be focused on leading the team, not making excuses.

“You’re one of the best players in the NFL,” Thomas said in a blunt interview. “If you want to be a true leader, stop blaming the rebuild. It’s time to step up and make the difference, not just point fingers.”

Thomas went on to explain that part of being a great player—especially one with Garrett’s talent—is finding ways to dominate even in difficult circumstances. The Browns’ rebuild, he argued, should be seen as an opportunity, not an obstacle.

For Thomas, Garrett’s frustrations seem misguided. As someone who spent years with a team in constant flux, Thomas believes that if you’re truly great, you find ways to elevate your team regardless of external circumstances. His challenge to Garrett wasn’t just about the team’s rebuilding process—it was about accountability.

“At some point, you have to stop waiting for the team to fix things and start fixing things yourself,” Thomas stated. “If you’re the player everyone thinks you are, you don’t wait around for a rebuild to be completed. You create change yourself.”

Is Garrett Overrated, or Just Stuck in a Bad Situation?

The tension between Garrett and Thomas raises a bigger question: Is Garrett overrated, or is he simply stuck in a bad situation that no amount of personal brilliance can overcome?

To say Garrett is overrated would be an overstatement—he’s a dominant player when he’s on the field, and his numbers back it up. However, Thomas’s criticism isn’t without merit. Garrett has yet to lead the Browns to a Super Bowl contender, despite his immense talent. This has caused some to wonder whether he’s living up to his full potential or if his frustrations are rooted in deeper insecurities about his leadership abilities.

Garrett’s complaints about the rebuild also highlight another important aspect of his personality—his desire for instant success. While other stars like Aaron Donald, J.J. Watt, and even Miles Garrett’s predecessor, Joe Thomas himself, had to endure years of losing seasons, they never publicly vented their frustrations in such a blaming manner. They kept working, kept improving, and, eventually, built successful teams around them.

Perhaps Garrett’s complaints are a sign that he lacks the necessary mental toughness to endure the hardship of rebuilding. This isn’t necessarily a shot at his skill or character—many great players struggle in the face of prolonged adversity. But it does raise questions about whether Garrett is truly built to carry the weight of a franchise, especially when times get tough.

The Bigger Picture: What Does This Mean for the Browns’ Future?

As the tension between Myles Garrett and Joe Thomas continues to simmer, the bigger question remains: What does this internal conflict mean for the future of the Cleveland Browns?

Garrett’s complaints about the rebuild could be the final straw in a season that’s already full of uncertainty. If the team is unable to come together—if players like Garrett aren’t willing to lead from within—then the Browns’ rebuild may stall for even longer.

At the same time, the rift between Garrett and Thomas highlights the broader challenges the Browns face in their efforts to climb out of mediocrity. If the franchise cannot keep its stars focused on the long-term vision, then the team will continue to languish in a cycle of rebuilding. No matter how many high-profile players they bring in, without strong leadership and accountability, the Browns will remain stuck in NFL purgatory.

Will Garrett Step Up or Keep Complaining?

Joe Thomas’ call to action was clear: If Myles Garrett wants to be considered among the NFL elite, he must stop focusing on the rebuild and start leading the Browns. But Garrett’s complaints suggest that he may not yet be ready for that responsibility.

As the Browns continue to navigate their rebuild, the pressure is mounting on Garrett to prove that he can be a franchise player who can overcome adversity—not someone who crumbles under it. If he wants to silence critics like Joe Thomas, Garrett will need to channel his frustrations into positive action, leading both on and off the field.

For now, the Browns remain in a state of flux. Only time will tell if Garrett can rise to the challenge—or if he will remain stuck in the cycle of frustration that has plagued the franchise for years.